PML-N hits back at Bilawal as the row over new provinces deepens

After Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari's Karachi speech, Asif, Tarar and MQM-P answered him. We set out who said what on new provinces and the referendum.

The white Parliament House building in Islamabad under a cloudy sky, with the Margalla Hills behind
Parliament House in Islamabad. (File photo) (Photo: Usman Ghani / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

Key points

  • PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari said at the Karachi Press Club on Tuesday that any forced attempt to divide Sindh would lead to bloodshed, and opposed a referendum on new provinces.
  • Defence Minister Khawaja Asif replied on X that anyone claiming equity must come with clean hands, and backed a debate in Parliament together with public opinion.
  • Information Minister Attaullah Tarar told Bilawal the two parties are part of the same government and invited him to sit down and talk.
  • MQM-P's Farooq Sattar demanded a nationwide referendum in December under Article 48(6) and asked that devolution be written into the proposed 28th Amendment.
  • Bilawal also called Imran Khan a political prisoner and urged the return of reserved seats to the PTI as a confidence-building step.

A public quarrel between the two main parties in the federal coalition widened on Wednesday over new provinces. Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, Information Minister Attaullah Tarar and MQM-P all answered Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, a day after he warned that dividing Sindh by force would lead to bloodshed, Dawn reported.

What Bilawal said

Speaking at the Karachi Press Club on Tuesday, Mr Bilawal made several points:

  • Sindh: he said no division should be imposed by force, and warned that if Sindh were divided forcibly, people would ask about “the blood” spilled on Karachi’s streets.
  • Referendum: he opposed the idea floated by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, saying that in Pakistan’s history a referendum has been used for undemocratic acts and never for democratic ones.
  • Process: neither the prime minister nor any member from the provinces has raised the issue with the president or with him, he said, and the cabinet has not discussed it, let alone Parliament.
  • The system: he said it has not collapsed but “has been made to collapse”, and acknowledged that everyone makes mistakes.
  • 27th Amendment: he said the 26th Amendment passed with a bilateral understanding if not full consensus, while the 27th passed on a “brute majority”. He said he was not asking for a rollback, but for engagement with the opposition on judicial reform. He had strongly advocated for the 27th Amendment when it passed a year ago, Dawn noted.
  • Imran Khan: he said Mr Khan is a political prisoner, called for an end to “vengeful actions”, and urged that reserved seats be returned to the PTI, without preconditions, as a confidence-building step.

How the government answered

Mr Tarar, who responded directly, suggested the criticism was largely a reaction to the public debate over new provinces. The two parties, he told Mr Bilawal, belong to the same government, and he invited him to come and sit down so that decisions can be made together.

Mr Asif wrote on X that whoever claims equity “must come with clean hands”, and asked whether Mr Bilawal’s hands were clean and whether he had the right to lecture or threaten. He argued that no system can be reset without public support, that Parliament should debate a reset, and that the public cannot be denied its basic right to be heard. He said no politician is exempt from accountability, noted that the PPP has governed Sindh for 18 years and said it has shared power with the PML-N since 2022.

Health Minister Mustafa Kamal, of MQM-P, asked why the PPP was worried about new provinces if its record in government was good, and said his party had tried to achieve devolution through the 26th and 27th Amendments, “but the PPP crushed” the move.

MQM-P’s demand

MQM-P senior leader Farooq Sattar asked for a nationwide referendum in December on new administrative units, under Article 48(6) of the Constitution, and for Article 140-A, which covers devolution to local governments, to be defined and included in the proposed 28th Amendment. He said the people, not political leaders, should decide. An MQM-P spokesperson also condemned Mr Bilawal’s remark, asking why bloodshed would occur only in Karachi and urban Sindh if provinces were created across the country.

Who says what

Actor Position on a referendum on new provinces
Mohsin Naqvi (interior minister) Floated it as the best way to end the debate; says parties will be consulted
Khawaja Asif (defence minister) Supports public opinion alongside Parliament; has backed up to 12 provinces on administrative lines
MQM-P Wants a nationwide referendum in December
PPP (Bilawal) Opposes it; warns of bloodshed if Sindh is divided by force
PTI Says Imran Khan has long supported new administrative units but wants public opinion to count

Background

This round follows Mr Naqvi’s referendum idea and Mr Asif’s earlier case for up to 12 provinces. Earlier this month Mr Bilawal also called for a “political reset” and asked the prime minister to rebuild trust with allies. His language on Tuesday was much sharper.

Why it matters

The PPP is a partner in the PML-N-led government, so a public row between the two parties matters more than a usual political spat. Nothing in the reports says a draft of the 28th Amendment or a formal proposal for new provinces exists, and the PPP chairman says the cabinet has not discussed it. The reports do not carry a government reply to that claim.

The sharpest edge is the warning about bloodshed. It raises the stakes of a debate that is, so far, about a referendum idea rather than a plan. Mr Tarar’s invitation to sit down is the next test: the PPP chairman said he would try to build consensus in his own party first before engaging others.

What to watch: whether the prime minister and Mr Bilawal meet, whether the government publishes a proposal, and whether the PPP answers MQM-P’s December demand.

Quick answers

What did Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari say about new provinces?

At the Karachi Press Club he said any forced attempt to carve up Sindh would lead to bloodshed, opposed a referendum, and said that neither the prime minister nor any provincial member had raised the issue with him or the president.

How did the government respond?

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar said the PPP and PML-N are part of the same government and invited Bilawal to sit down and decide together. Defence Minister Khawaja Asif said anyone claiming equity must come with clean hands, and that Parliament and the public should both be heard.

What does MQM-P want?

MQM-P's Farooq Sattar called for a nationwide referendum on new administrative units in December under Article 48(6) of the Constitution, and for devolution to local governments under Article 140-A to be defined in the proposed 28th Amendment.

Topics

Spotted an error? See our corrections policy ortell our newsroom.